Meet Jack Crowley, President of Water Street Mission

Brought to you by High Foundation, Reach High is a series that introduces nonprofit leaders who are thoughtfully innovating with a spirit of servant leadership.

When Jack Crowley took a two-month, post-grad summer job at Water Street Mission, he had no idea that it would blossom into a cumulative 30 years serving the Lancaster City nonprofit. 

Working in ministry wasn’t even on his radar as he entered his freshman year at Franklin & Marshall College with the intention of “becoming a lawyer and making lots of money,” as he puts it. 

It was one formative experience and two passionate professors during his college years that would plant the seeds that Jack would faithfully follow in the years to come. 

“My first summer in college, I worked at a camp in the Poconos, and that was where my faith was reinvigorated,” Jack shared. “Then my plans to be a lawyer and dominate the world didn’t fit with who Jesus was and was calling me to be.” 

He changed his major to government and psychology and met Professor Jim Schultz and Dr. Michael Penn. The former opened Jack’s eyes to urban politics while the latter invited him to do research with him. 

“For that research project, I spent a lot of time interviewing kids in juvenile detention centers,” he shared. “I started to see myself in those kids who had gone down a wrong path.” 

During his teenage years, Jack admits to making a number of decisions that could have had similar consequences to the kids he interviewed. 

“That was where I felt things coming together and God saying, ‘You need to use what I’ve given you to walk with others who don’t have anybody walking with them.’” he explained.

Jack was offered a temporary job with what would become Water Street’s Teen Haven program, working with junior high students at a day camp program and living within the men’s dorms. After that summer, he was asked to commit to two more years.

“When the students saw I was still around, they started asking when I was leaving for good,” he remembers. “I realized how damaging it was to them to have people cycle in and out so I told God I’d stay as long he wanted me to be there.”

Jack has remained a part of Water Street for over three decades, even continuing to volunteer during a brief time when he was employed elsewhere. His roles have grown, shifted, and stretched him over the years, as he ultimately became the President in 2015. Throughout it all, his commitment to their mission to walk with neighbors through their journeys to restoration has not wavered.

“My approach as a leader remains being faithful to the heartbeat of Water Street—who we are supposed to be in this community and who God has called us to be.” Jack shared.

To learn more about the work of Water Street Mission, visit wsm.org. 


Find out more about High Foundation’s mission to be a Bridge to Opportunity for the Lancaster community at highfoundation.org.

Want to discover more local? Follow Fig on Facebook and Instagram for inspiration.

More from Fig

Your Weekly Guide to Lancaster

Delivered right to your inbox for free, Fig Weekly features local stories, small business features, and upcoming events you won’t want to miss.

By signing up, I agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Fresh Figs Delivered to You

Designed and produced four times a year, Fig Lancaster magazine is filled with the latest in Lancaster including local shopping, dining, arts, events, and community.