Here’s The Scoop: Where To Find Delicious Ice Cream In Lancaster City

Here are some of our favorite ice cream spots in Lancaster City.

There is no shortage of ice cream spots in Lancaster City!

Here’s the scoop on some great places find your favorite ice cream, milkshakes, floats, and sundaes.

Lancaster Cupcake

What makes Lancaster Cupcake cupcakes even better? Combining them with a creamy, frozen soft serve ice cream! Choose one of your favorite cupcake flavors for this special Cupcake Split treat. We also love the Mega Cake Shakes offered (a signature milkshake served in a souvenir glass frosted with icing and toppings, finished with whipped cream, toppings, and your favorite cupcake stacked on top). Check out the milkshakes and sundaes as well!  

Where: 24 West Orange Street, 260 Granite Run Drive, and 501 Park City Center

Splits & Giggles

  There are so many options at Splits & Giggles to satisfy your ice cream craving. We love the Giggles Parfait (three scoops of your choice of ice cream layered with three toppings of your choice) and the Banana Split (traditional banana split with chocolate, vanilla, and strawberry ice cream that is topped with strawberries, pineapple, and chocolate syrup, served in a parfait cup with whipped cream and a cherry on top). Or feel free to browse their many ice cream flavors and choose a cone, a cup, a milkshake, or ice cream float.  

Where: 500 West Lemon Street

Rolled Cold Creamery

At Rolled Cold, customers can choose from a huge menu full of delicious flavors. You can explore The Originals—flavors that are consistently featured at the shop like Chocolate Brownie (a best seller!), Blueberry, Peanut Butter Cup, Cookies and Cream, Caramel Pretzel, Mint Chocolate Chip, and more. Plus, there are seasonal flavors rotating throughout the menu.   You can pick a flavor, or choose a custom flavor by selecting a specific cream, mix-in, topping, and sauce. And don’t forget your dish choices! In addition to standard cups, there are waffle cone shells (with a vegan option!).  

Where: 24 East Orange Street

Penny’s Ice Cream

Check out the great assortment of ice cream treats at this adorable parlor on Prince. From waffle cones to milkshakes, this has it all. We love The PBO Sundae (Peanut Butter Oreo Ice Cream, peanut butter cup crumbles, and hot fudge) and The Brownie Sundae (vanilla ice cream, Wendy Jo’s brownies, and hot fudge). Or browse their fantastic variety of ice cream flavors and make your own!  

Where: 228 North Prince Street

Miesse Candies

New to Miesse Candies is an old fashioned ice cream parlor experience. Choose from classic ice cream flavors or make an old fashioned milkshake or float. A warm summer day is the perfect opportunity to check out this new addition to Miesse Candies! While you are there, browse their selection of handcrafted chocolates, caramels, hand-dipped chocolate pretzels & fruit, and other delicious candies.  

Where: 118 North Water Street

Lancaster Sweet Shoppe

This place is super sweet. Known for their authentic Dutch Stroopwafel cookies, Lancaster Sweet Shoppe is the perfect spot for sweets. Choose from an assortment of ice cream flavors—one of which has stroopwafels within the ice cream itself! You can also get milkshakes made with any of the available ice cream options. Don’t forget while you are there to try their freshly-made stroopwafels and other handcrafted candies.  

Where: 141 North Duke Street

More from Fig

Food & Drink

Treat yourself at Nikki’s Custard

Fueled by a craving for her favorite dessert, Nicole Dannehl is bringing authentic frozen custard to Lancaster one scoop at a time.

Your Weekly Guide to Lancaster

Delivered right to your inbox for free, Fig Weekly features local stories, small business features, and upcoming events you won’t want to miss.

By signing up, I agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.